Great American Whiskey

Now is the time to praise traditional straight whiskey. While we applaud the recent craft-spirit movement, we hasten to recall America’s more-than-two-century heritage in making straight whiskies of superior age with a few innovations of their own.

Maker’s Mark spiced up its Bourbon this summer, releasing the distillery’s first line extension since 1958. Maker’s 46 is a collaboration of the master distiller and cask maker. They make a Bourbon just like the original and then give it an extra finish by dipping 10 French oak staves, which have been quickly seared at high temperature, into the barrel for about 11 weeks. The supremely smooth liquor gets a zest of licorice in the bargain.

A close look at the superpremiums Booker’s, Baker’s, Basil Hayden’s and Knob Creek (expect a single-barrel expression soon) of the Original Small Batch Bourbon Collection reveals that they are Jim Beam products. Jim Beam Black, the double-aged version of standard Beam with the big taste and the approachable price, has no such identity issue. Fred Noe, son of Booker, is the seventh-generation Beam at the still house.

Wild Turkey’s Jimmy Russell is the distiller’s distiller and his (along with son Eddie’s) Russell’s Reserve Small Batch 10 Year Old exemplifies their craft with plenty of maple, vanilla, oak and orange peel. At 90 proof, it’s a little less forbidding than Turkey’s signature 101 strength.

Jack Daniel’s is the Bourbon everyone thinks they know. And they do,—it just isn’t Bourbon, but a close cousin called Tennessee Sour Mash Whiskey. (George Dickel is similarly made.) Both are made like Bourbon, then are filtered through charcoal.  Jack Daniel’s Single Barrel came from serendipity when, in the early 1990s, space utilized in warehouse attics was found to give the whiskey extra maturation.

Woodford Reserve is made in one of Kentucky’s most storied distilleries in copper-pot stills. The spirit is smooth and the taste sweet, with cherry, vanilla and caramel. Woodford periodically experiments with its Master’s Collection. The latest has a maple-wood finish.

Bulleit Bourbon, like Basil Hayden’s, is marked by a high rye content in its mash bill. The spicy jolt—prescribed by an old family recipe from the founder’s great-great-grandfather—is reminiscent of the frontier.

Heaven Hill, the last family-owned distillery in Kentucky, makes the venerable Elijah Craig Bourbon and beguiling Rittenhouse straight ryes. Our favorite is Evan Williams’ Single Barrel Vintage, another great buy. Master distiller Parker Beam, great nephew of Jim, personally picks the barrels for a new version of this 10-year-old each year.

They’ve made spirits under different names at Buffalo Trace since before the revolution, conjuring such storied whiskies as Blanton’s Single Barrel, Elmer T. Lee and George T. Stagg. Now add the Eagle Rare Single Barrel, a distinct 10-year-old at value price, with maple sugar and orange notes.

Bourbon Whiskey
"Throw a little love @ Buffalo Trace + my fav." —January 10, 2012 00:59 AM
"I have to say, Maker's Mark 46 is one of my favorites, considering I am a Dalmore fan. My Father tried it during his last visit here in Delaware, and absolutely loved it. " —January 29, 2011 15:49 PM
"I love my bourbons and ryes. This past year I particularly enjoyed the great Black Maple Hill and the Van Winkle 13 year old. 2011 should provide some new tastes. Can't wait!" —January 3, 2011 16:50 PM
"newyears day celabrating with friends in my mancave with some knobcreek and padilla don;t get much better than this." —January 1, 2011 12:28 PM
"At the moment I'm loving Black Maple Hill and Elijah Craig 18 year... Blantons is definitely in my top five. " —December 31, 2010 13:53 PM
"Don't forget Willet's. It's some of the best I've ever had. Seek it out if you can. Highly recommended." —December 30, 2010 23:02 PM
"Basil is one of the top bourbons on the market but Woodford is a close 2nd." —December 30, 2010 22:05 PM
"Hey Jack, love the article. A good bourbon is a thing of beauty. Have you ever done, or would you consider a similar article on Canadian Rye Whiskey's?" —December 30, 2010 11:50 AM
"I agree! Great article I am a bourbon guy: My favorites in no particular order: Knob Creek, Woodford Reserve, Jack Daniels Single Barrel is pretty good also. If I had to pick one to go with a Partagas Black label I think it would be the Knob, but they are all great" —December 30, 2010 11:19 AM
"Liquid gold, baby. Having some Knob Creek right now with a mild cigar." —December 9, 2010 22:12 PM
"Great article Jack. The only way it could be better would be to make it 20 pages long. Love those Bourbons. " —November 19, 2010 21:37 PM

More in Drinks Pairings

See all
2021 Big Smoke Seminars: An Iconic Tasting of Rum And Cigars

2021 Big Smoke Seminars: An Iconic Tasting of Rum And Cigars

There is a very strong parallel between the Bacardí rum family and the families behind storied cigars …

Nov 9, 2021
Cigar of the Year Meets Whisky of the Year

Cigar of the Year Meets Whisky of the Year

The makers of the No. 1 cigar and the No. 1 whisky guide the audience through the sublimely synergist…

Nov 2, 2021
After 100 Years, Jack Daniel’s Shows Its Age

After 100 Years, Jack Daniel’s Shows Its Age

The world’s top-selling American whiskey is marketing a bottle with an age statement: Jack Daniel’s …

Sep 8, 2021
Perfect Pairings: Michter’s Bourbon And The Eye of the Shark

Perfect Pairings: Michter’s Bourbon And The Eye of the Shark

A 10-year-old Bourbon from and former Cigar of the Year pair superbly in this taste test.

Aug 31, 2021
Pairing Stone Sublimely Self-Righteous Black IPA with Cigars

Pairing Stone Sublimely Self-Righteous Black IPA with Cigars

A cult-classic beer brought back from the dead with two excellent cigars.

Feb 25, 2021
The Pairings: Rum Meets Cigars

The Pairings: Rum Meets Cigars

To demonstrate the many options for marrying rum and smoke, we picked two cigars with quite different …

Aug 14, 2020