Where to Smoke

The Carnegie Club, New York City

Sep 24, 2012 | By Andrew Nagy
The Carnegie Club, New York City

In this era of extreme tobacco legislation in New York City, it’s reassuring to know that a real cigar bar such as The Carnegie Club—where alcohol and cigars are legally served aside one another—still exists.

Carved out of the back of Carnegie Hall by Mark Grossich's Hospitality Holdings Group in 1996, The Carnegie Club has been serving cigar enthusiasts ever since. Thanks to an exemption, the club managed to survive Mayor Michael Bloomberg’s infamous workplace smoking ban that was passed in 2003, and it now represents the upper-echelon of establishments that can legally mix drink and smoke.

Recently, the club’s interior underwent a series of upgrades by New York design house Goodman and Charlton. All new furniture, tables, carpets, wallpaper, window treatments and artwork have breathed new life into the space, which can accommodate around 150 guests. While the theme of The Carnegie Club still remains something like an 18th century Gothic library, three new flat-screen televisions as well as a new sound system have been added, giving the club a pleasantly distinct lounge feel.

The club makes good use of these new televisions and speakers, using them for football games and boxing matches, plus to augment the live musical acts it books so patrons can watch from anywhere in the space—a good idea, given the 25-foot tall ceilings and large mezzanine area situated above the main floor. Every Friday, a rotating list of jazz musicians plays the club. Sinatra Saturdays with Steve Maglio, an interpreter of Ol’ Blue Eyes’ music, is also a popular ticket.

The club has also worked with area retailer Davidoff to ramp up its cigar menu, which includes cigars from brands like Padrón (both 1926 and 1964 Series), La Flor Dominicana, Davidoff, Alec Bradley, Ashton, Nestor Miranda, Romeo y Julieta and even a house blend. While the club marks up the prices of its cigars significantly, it will waive the $10 cutting fee for any smoker who brings in a cigar with a sales receipt from an area retailer (Davidoff and De La Concha being the closest). It’s tough, though, to put a price on the cost to freely smoke in a public bar.

Carnegie Club also offers an extensive drinks list. In addition to wine by the glass, the club carries an impressive array of brandies, Scotches, Bourbons, rums and beers. Additionally, a cocktail menu that includes classics like the Churchill, Mojito and Sazerac, among others, are available, along with a number of specialities specially prepared by the club.

If you’re in the mood for an elegant night out, or simply want to spite Mr. Bloomberg and revel in the freedom of smoking in a public bar, remember The Carnegie Club, one of the city’s finest smoking establishments.

The Carnegie Club
156 West 56th Street
New York, NY 10019
(212) 957-9676
Reservations are welcome
Monday to Friday: 2 p.m. - 2 a.m.
Saturday: 4 p.m. - 2 a.m.
Sundays: 4 p.m. - 1 a.m.

"Terrible service... I was there with a friend sitting at the bar and we were asked to leave (or pay an entrance fee) because there was some show/concert starting... We had just got drinks!! They should have warned us when we sat down that at a certain time a ticketed event would be starting! I used to go there once every couple months - no more!" —November 12, 2013 19:22 PM
"A fantastic place. I was in NYC on business a couple of weeks ago (visiting from New Zealand) and fancied a post-dinner cigar and whisky (or 3!), so visited on my own. I had a superb night. Great jazz band playing, incredibly friendly crowd, very wide selection of single malts available and excellent barman. In every respect a first class establishment - I'll be sure to visit when I'm next in town." —June 6, 2013 17:46 PM
"A fantastic place. I was in NYC on business a couple of weeks ago (visiting from New Zealand) and fancied a post-dinner cigar and whisky (or 3!), so visited on my own. I had a superb night. Great jazz band playing, incredibly friendly crowd, very wide selection of single malts available and excellent barman. In every respect a first class establishment - I'll be sure to visit when I'm next in town." —June 6, 2013 17:45 PM
"Firstly, thank you for the informative and very enjoyable article. However, based upon the pictures and your description of the club, I believe you might have meant the 19th century? That being said, thanks to you and Cigar Aficionado, I am without a doubt looking forward to a visit! " —October 16, 2012 06:31 AM
"@Chris - They have indeed installed an all new smoke-eater system. Very powerful. " —September 25, 2012 15:37 PM
"Hey Andrew, I didnt read anything about a new exhaust system, did they upgrade the existing one? Last time I was there it was pretty bad, the smoke was not venting & the place was filled with smoke, my eyes started tearing up." —September 25, 2012 06:26 AM
"Another fine place to smoke in city that seems to not value its cigar smokers except for their tax dollars. Looking forward to dropping in for a visit." —September 24, 2012 18:10 PM

More in Where to Smoke

See all
And The #MyCigarSpace Winner Is….

And The #MyCigarSpace Winner Is….

Our #MyCigarSpace Contest revealed an impressive array of great places to smoke cigars. After …

May 26, 2020
Voting Opens For #MyCigarSpace Reader Contest

Voting Opens For #MyCigarSpace Reader Contest

After receiving hundreds of submissions, the editors have selected the finalists and now it’s your …

May 11, 2020
#MyCigarSpace Reader Contest Instructions

#MyCigarSpace Reader Contest Instructions

The way to enter is simple: snap a picture of your favorite smoking spot and share it on social media …

Apr 9, 2020
Where To Smoke: Cigar Lounge, La Réserve Hotel Genève, Switzerland

Where To Smoke: Cigar Lounge, La Réserve Hotel Genève, Switzerland

While most of Geneva’s top hotels sit in the business district, La Réserve is an expansive urban …

Mar 6, 2020
Review: Agua Caliente, Rancho Mirage, California

Review: Agua Caliente, Rancho Mirage, California

A cigar oasis in the desert.

Feb 19, 2020
Review: Cigar Point, Mexico City, Mexico

Review: Cigar Point, Mexico City, Mexico

Located in Mexico City’s Roma neighborhood, Cigar Point offers both indoor and outdoor smoking areas …

Jan 28, 2020