Get 1 Year of Cigar Aficionado for Just $24.95 + A Free Gift!

Drinks Pairings

Perfect Pairings: Michter’s Bourbon And The Eye of the Shark

Aug 31, 2021 | By Jack Bettridge
Perfect Pairings: Michter’s Bourbon And The Eye of the Shark

If you got outbid at last year’s charity auction in London, where a full cask of Michter’s 10-year-old Single Barrel Bourbon set a record at $209,000, don’t fret. The limited-edition whiskey is again available in its annual release. While it still isn’t cheap, it may seem affordable by comparison at $150 a bottle.

Once you taste it, you might not be as charitable with your pals who show up with a thirst. It’s the kind of whiskey you pour out in dribs and drabs and horde for when you have a special cigar to enjoy it with.

Michter’s issues the whiskey once each year. As it’s a single-barrel Bourbon, slight differences occur not only from year to year, but from cask to cask. (The bottles are numbered by barrel.) However, the tasting staff does its best to replicate the 10-Year-Old’s signature taste, which a complex melding of fruit and caramel candies.

Michter’s, which is named for a storied and shuttered distillery in Pennsylvania, now operates as part of Chatham Imports in Kentucky. The company reinvented the brand as negotiant of spirits, buying special casks from established distilleries and chill-filtering the contents for packaging under the brand name Michter’s. Many of their labels are of this age and older.

The company has since opened a distillery in Louisville, Kentucky. It has been one of the spearheads of the revitalization of the Bourbon industry in the state’s largest city. Distillers many years ago occupied a prominent place in the city, but departed for the countryside. The Bourbon of the last few decades has begun to reverse that trend. 

The Pairing:

Michter’s makes a variety of whiskeys, including Bourbon and rye. Given its age, this 10-year-old will still be the product of procured whiskeys, as spirit from the new distillery will not be available for a while. In the meantime, here’s a cigar pairing that may get you through the wait.

Michter's Single Barrel Bourbon 10 Years Old (94.4 proof, $150, Barrel no. 21D1204)

Appearance: Amber/copper color with excruciatingly slow legs. 

Nose: Fruity-cherry, orange triple sec, with caramel.

Palate: Tangy cherry, maple candy, currants, bit of licorice.

Finish: Picks up spice on the finish. Fruit lulls and then returns in waves.

Arturo Fuente Don Carlos Eye of the Shark (5 1/4 inches by 50 ring, $14.35, 97 points, Cigar of the Year for 2017)

This partially pressed belicoso draws and burns with textbook precision, enveloping the palate with opulent layers of walnut, almond, chocolate and baking spice notes brought together by a citrus undertone. A delicious smoke.

The Pairing: This is a textbook example of two elements that create a pairing greater than its sum. The cigar finds chocolate and nuts on the whiskey, while accentuating its caramel. The Michter’s in the meantime makes leather pop on the Fuente and reveals its sweet side with the Bourbon’s own contribution of fruit.

Arturo Fuente

More in Drinks Pairings

See all
After 100 Years, Jack Daniel’s Shows Its Age

After 100 Years, Jack Daniel’s Shows Its Age

The world’s top-selling American whiskey is marketing a bottle with an age statement: Jack Daniel’s …

Sep 8, 2021
Pairing Stone Sublimely Self-Righteous Black IPA with Cigars

Pairing Stone Sublimely Self-Righteous Black IPA with Cigars

A cult-classic beer brought back from the dead with two excellent cigars.

Feb 25, 2021
The Pairings: Rum Meets Cigars

The Pairings: Rum Meets Cigars

To demonstrate the many options for marrying rum and smoke, we picked two cigars with quite different …

Aug 14, 2020
Four Irish Whiskies to Pair With Your Next Cigar

Four Irish Whiskies to Pair With Your Next Cigar

The world of Irish whiskey has enjoyed a bit of a resurgence in recent years. We paired four standout …

Mar 17, 2020
Bonding with Bourbon

Bonding with Bourbon

We pair 16 outstanding Bourbons with cigars to demonstrate the classic American whiskey's affinity …

Mar 10, 2020
Pairing Laphroaig 16 With Cuban Cigars

Pairing Laphroaig 16 With Cuban Cigars

A Hoyo Epicure No. 2 and a Cohiba Siglo V go head-to-head with Laphroaig's new expression.

Dec 6, 2019