1 Year of Cigar Aficionado for $10 PLUS a Free Gift!

Legislation

Judge Declines to Extend Substantial Equivalence Deadline to Cigar Industry

Oct 21, 2019 | By Andrew Nagy
Judge Declines to Extend Substantial Equivalence Deadline to Cigar Industry

A judge in Washington D.C. has denied the cigar industry’s request to extend the deadline for a key product approval rule known as Substantial Equivalence.

Substantial Equivalence is one of the three pathways to product approval that the FDA established when it published its Final Deeming Rule in May 2016. According to the FDA, a cigar manufacturer must file an SE report to show that a new tobacco product has similar characteristics to a grandfathered (predicate) tobacco product, or has different characteristics, but doesn't raise any new questions of public health. A predicate tobacco product is one that was on the market on February 15, 2007.

Judge Amit P. Mehta of United States District Court for the District of Columbia filed his ruling on Friday, saying that the cigar industry failed to establish that the new Substantial Equivalence deadline is unfair to cigar manufacturers. The motion was filed in July on behalf of the Cigar Rights of America, Cigar Association of America and Premium Cigar Association.

“That is because the predicament in which Plaintiffs find themselves—facing an earlier deadline to comply with a new statutory substantial equivalence requirement—was caused not by any action or inaction by the Food and Drug Administration; rather, it is entirely a function of a judicial ruling,” wrote Judge Mehta in his ruling.

Earlier this year, the Substantial Equivalence deadline was moved up to May 2020 by a judge’s ruling in a Maryland court case called American Academy of Pediatrics v. FDA.

Back in July 2017, then-FDA commissioner Dr. Scott Gottlieb extended the SE report deadline to August 2021, and this deadline was recognized by Judge Mehta.

FDA

More in Legislation

See all
Court Strikes Down Key Premarket Review Process for Premium Cigars

Court Strikes Down Key Premarket Review Process for Premium Cigars

Premium cigar manufacturers no longer have to worry about the upcoming September 9 deadline for some …

Aug 19, 2020
FDA Asks Court to Consider Premium Cigar Deferral Proposal

FDA Asks Court to Consider Premium Cigar Deferral Proposal

As the September 9 deadline for cigar manufacturers to submit their premarket applications to the FDA …

Aug 6, 2020
Pennsylvania Reps Prod President to Eliminate Premium Cigar Regulations

Pennsylvania Reps Prod President to Eliminate Premium Cigar Regulations

Half of Pennsylvania’s 18 representatives earlier this week signed and sent a letter to President …

Jul 15, 2020
Court Strikes Down FDA’s Cigar Warning Label Plan

Court Strikes Down FDA’s Cigar Warning Label Plan

A trio of judges on the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Washington D.C. Circuit ruled unanimously this …

Jul 7, 2020
Florida Representatives Urge President to Drop Cigar Industry Regulations

Florida Representatives Urge President to Drop Cigar Industry Regulations

In response to the economic downturn, a dozen representatives from Florida have signed and sent a …

Jun 8, 2020
Court Ruling Ends Chances of 2021 Deadline for FDA Product Reports

Court Ruling Ends Chances of 2021 Deadline for FDA Product Reports

The FDA’s pre-market application deadline for cigars will remain September 9 after a trio of judges …

May 5, 2020