Where to Smoke

Diamante's Brooklyn Cigar Lounge, New York City

Mar 7, 2013 | By Phil Scott
Diamante's Brooklyn Cigar Lounge, New York City

Diamante’s Brooklyn Cigar Lounge is a worn, comfy place, ensconced in the first floor of a Fort Greene brownstone, just a few blocks from the brand-new Barclays Center, the new home of the NBA’s Brooklyn Nets basketball team. It looks to be about a century-and-a-half old, with its unvarnished wooden flooring and copper ceiling, leather furniture, old fixtures and ancient photos of owner David Diamante’s family.

One picture goes all the way back to 1911, a group shot in front of another brownstone just a few blocks away, which includes his great-great grandfather, great-grandfather and great-uncles, all in suits, all gripping cigars.

“This place is my place,” Diamante says. “I’m not going to sell a bad cigar—my name is over the door.”

Yet his place is not as old as it looks. In fact, back when Diamante first bought the building in 2009, the walls had holes punched in them and were painted pink; overhead hung three florescent lights, and the floor was plywood. He chose to lay unfinished floor boards and filled the room with antique fixtures and ancient woods, giving it its turn-of-the-last-century ambiance. And, of course, the framed family photos.

There are other photos as well, boxers like Muhammad Ali, Carmen Basilio, Tony DeMarco and a few other fighters from the '40s and '50s. See, Diamante, with his waist-length dreadlocks and flat cap, announces fights for HBO, Showtime and ESPN; he’s also the voice of the Brooklyn Nets and hosts his own daily morning television show on the NBC Sports Network.

An inveterate traveler of fairly dangerous places—he's hitchhiked across Somalia and recently returned from Ethiopia—he’s also logged time in Cuba, Nicaragua, Honduras, and the Dominican Republic, learning about cigars. “It’s one of those things that you need to know the nuts and bolts to talk about it from an educated perspective,” he says.

The glass humidor above the bar is packed with name brands like Padrón, Tatuaje, Dominican versions of Cohiba, Montecristo and Romeo y Julieta, and the most expensive, the $34 Fuente Fuente OpusX.

“We try to cover all the main brands,” he says. “They’re not cheap, and they’re not expensive.” The shop normally charges a $10 cutting fee, but this is waved with the purchase of a cigar.

Every Wednesday is ladies night with special discounts for women. Tuesday is classic fight night. Occasionally they have a DJ or live jazz. “We are happy to be a part of the fabric of the community,” he adds.

Diamante’s pride is stacked inside the glass-and-Spanish-cedar humidor on the bar; his own brand of handrolled cigars separated into mild-, medium- and full-bodied. From the humidor he selects two pyramid cigars with a shaggy foot, and we sit back and relax in two leather chairs and fire them up.

Like all the other cigars from Diamante's cigar line, they’re rolled in the Dominican Republic. They’re pretty cigars, smooth and flavorful—yet fierce.

“Cigars should be smoked for one of three reasons: conversation, contemplation or celebration,” he says. “Life is too short to smoke bad cigars.”

Brooklyn Cigar Lounge
108 South Oxford Street
Fort Greene, Brooklyn, NY 11217

Monday - Thursday: 5 p.m. - midnight
Friday: 5 p.m. - 2 a.m.
Saturday: 1 p.m. - 2 a.m.
Sunday: 1 p.m. - midnight

"Some of my friends and I celebrated my birthday at Diamante's Cigar Lounge this summer ...... We had a BLAST! The atmosphere was great and the service was AWESOME!! I recommend anyone in Brooklyn that wants to just chill and relax with a (Cuban) Montecristo ( my favorite! ) this is the place to be!! Can't wait to visit you guys again!!....Thank you ^.^! " —November 18, 2014 13:27 PM
"I've heard about this place so often, I might have to visit one day, when the weather gets better. Kudos, Mr. Diamante!" —March 10, 2013 14:36 PM

More in Where to Smoke

See all
Schweizerhof Hotel, Zermatt, Switzerland

Schweizerhof Hotel, Zermatt, Switzerland

The Schweizerhof Hotel is arguably the best luxury hotel in the mountain town of Zermatt, Switzerland…

Aug 3, 2022
Legacy Club, Circa Casino Resort, Las Vegas

Legacy Club, Circa Casino Resort, Las Vegas

Exceptional views, cigars, and drinks are all on the menu at the Legacy Club atop the new Circa …

Jun 8, 2022
America’s Cigar-Friendly Casinos

America’s Cigar-Friendly Casinos

There are more than 900 casinos across the United States, and most will throw you out if you light a …

May 23, 2022
Cuban Creations, New Orleans, Louisiana

Cuban Creations, New Orleans, Louisiana

Cuban Creations, a full-service cigar bar in the French Quarter, was once a fancy bath house, and the …

May 9, 2022
Doc James Cigar Lounge, Mamaroneck, New York

Doc James Cigar Lounge, Mamaroneck, New York

In Westchester County’s quaint village of Mamaroneck, Josh DeSiena, owner of the Doc James Cigar …

Apr 8, 2022
Bombay Club, New Orleans

Bombay Club, New Orleans

The Bombay Club offers classic cocktails, live music, an intimate atmosphere and a cigar-friendly …

Feb 28, 2022