1 Year of Cigar Aficionado for $10 PLUS a Free Gift!

Legislation

Court Reinstates New York State Park Smoking Ban

Jan 14, 2015 | By Andrew Nagy
Court Reinstates New York State Park Smoking Ban

No-smoking signs will be returning to New York state public parks in the near future after a mid-level court recently reinstated a smoking ban that had previously been reversed due to a challenge from a smoker advocacy group.

Five judges serving on New York State Supreme Court, Appellate Division, Third Department, ruled on December 21, 2014 that the state Office of Parks, Recreation, and Historical Preservation did not exceed its authority when it originally banned smoking from state parks and historic sites in 2012.

"All aspects of the regulation are grounded in (the agency's) stated purpose—to allow all patrons to enjoy the fresh air and natural beauty of its outdoor facilities," Justice Karen Peters wrote in her opinion.

In other words, it is once again illegal to smoke in New York state's historic sites and 178 public parks such as Bear Mountain State Park, Bethpage and even the seven state parks in New York City, including Riverbank State Park in Manhattan.

When the ban was first enacted in 2012, a smoker advocacy group called NYC C.L.A.S.H. (Citizens Lobbying Against Smoker Harassment) sent a letter to the Parks Department that challenged the constitutionality of the smoking ban.

The letter pointed out that the New York State Legislature had rejected more than 19 bills that called for a state park smoking ban. It stated that the Parks Department exceeded its authority when it passed the smoking ban and superseded the Legislature's will.

In response to that letter, the State Parks Department voluntarily suspended its own ban, stating at the time that it would enter a full rulemaking process, including public hearings, as it sought a way to reintroduce the ban. The ban was reinstated again by the agency in February 2013.

However, in 2013, Supreme Court Justice George Ceresia sided with NYC C.L.A.S.H. after it filed a lawsuit against the state in which it argued that the ban opposed the wishes of state lawmakers and exceeded the department's authority.

It was this ruling that the judges overturned on December 31.

Smoking Ban
"Yes and what about all those giant motorhomes and travel trailers sitting there with generators and/or engines idling all day and night!" —January 21, 2015 19:26 PM
""All aspects of the regulation are grounded in (the agency's) stated purpose—to allow all patrons to enjoy the fresh air and natural beauty of its outdoor facilities," Justice Karen Peters wrote in her opinion. Then they need to ban campfires too. Duh huh! What's worse, the tiny bit of smoke emitted by a cigar, or a blazing campfire stinking up the entire camp site and everyone near it? This is harassment, and that's all it is. Pure and simple." —January 15, 2015 12:02 PM
"You folks better start dumping some money toward CLASH! Is the CRA doing anything about this?" —January 15, 2015 02:44 AM

More in Legislation

See all
Court Strikes Down Key Premarket Review Process for Premium Cigars

Court Strikes Down Key Premarket Review Process for Premium Cigars

Premium cigar manufacturers no longer have to worry about the upcoming September 9 deadline for some …

Aug 19, 2020
FDA Asks Court to Consider Premium Cigar Deferral Proposal

FDA Asks Court to Consider Premium Cigar Deferral Proposal

As the September 9 deadline for cigar manufacturers to submit their premarket applications to the FDA …

Aug 6, 2020
Pennsylvania Reps Prod President to Eliminate Premium Cigar Regulations

Pennsylvania Reps Prod President to Eliminate Premium Cigar Regulations

Half of Pennsylvania’s 18 representatives earlier this week signed and sent a letter to President …

Jul 15, 2020
Court Strikes Down FDA’s Cigar Warning Label Plan

Court Strikes Down FDA’s Cigar Warning Label Plan

A trio of judges on the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Washington D.C. Circuit ruled unanimously this …

Jul 7, 2020
Florida Representatives Urge President to Drop Cigar Industry Regulations

Florida Representatives Urge President to Drop Cigar Industry Regulations

In response to the economic downturn, a dozen representatives from Florida have signed and sent a …

Jun 8, 2020
Court Ruling Ends Chances of 2021 Deadline for FDA Product Reports

Court Ruling Ends Chances of 2021 Deadline for FDA Product Reports

The FDA’s pre-market application deadline for cigars will remain September 9 after a trio of judges …

May 5, 2020