Cigar Industry

2019 Big Smoke Saturday Seminars: Fighting the FDA

Nov 20, 2019 | By David Savona
2019 Big Smoke Saturday Seminars: Fighting the FDA
Photos/Jacob Kepler
The FDA panel. From left: moderator Andrew Nagy, Drew Newman, Glynn Loope and Rocky Patel.

The FDA has become an unwanted partner in the cigar business, and the final topic on Saturday before breaking for lunch focused on the government agency and how its regulations affect how cigars are made, marketed and enjoyed in the United States. 

Andrew Nagy of Cigar Aficionado moderated the panel. Nagy, who has been with Cigar Aficionado for 11 years, is the associate editor of the magazine, and one of his regular duties is covering the changing world of FDA regulation.

“Everyone’s favorite subject,” he said with an ironic smile. “It’s a messy situation. It’s complicated.”

Joining Nagy on stage were Rocky Patel, the owner of Rocky Patel Premium Cigars; Drew Newman, general counsel for J.C. Newman Cigar Co., and Glynn Loope, executive director of the Cigar Rights of America.

Patel spoke of the difficulty of creating new products, given FDA limitations that stifle creativity, requiring new cigars to be similar to those that were on the market before the regulations went into effect.

Big Smoke 2019 Rocky Patel
Rocky Patel during the FDA panel, discussing the never-ending fight against over-regulation of cigars.

“It’s a very difficult time and situation,” said Patel, who spends much of his time fighting for the rights of cigar smokers. “Our industry is so innovative. People are looking for new releases, new taste profiles, new sizes. The FDA tied our hands and limited us.”

The panelists pointed out that FDA cigar regulations were built to mimic cigarette regulations—restrictions that don’t work with a handmade product like cigars. “It’s not like making a cigarette in a machine,” said Patel. “We can’t conform and make everything the same.”

“Premium cigars are different,” concurred Newman. “You can’t regulate them like cigarettes. The cigar industry is not sitting on its hands. We want to fight so you all have the right to enjoy a premium cigar.”

Nagy asked the panel if there were people in the U.S. government who were on the side of cigar smokers. “We have friends,” said Loope, who called this a bipartisan fight. “We’ve got hardcore liberals and hardcore conservatives supporting this legislation. This battle is at both ends of Pennsylvania Avenue, with a courthouse in between.”

Big Smoke 2019 Fighting the FDA
Moderator Andrew Nagy of Cigar Aficionado, hosting the panel on FDA regulation.

The panel urged members of the audience to reach out to their representatives in the government to urge them to support the premium cigar industry. “You are no longer a cigar smoker, you are a cigar voter,” said Loope.

“We need your help,” said Newman.

The panelists spoke about how the premium cigar industry, which sells roughly 360 million handmade cigars annually, was a tiny portion of the overall cigar market, which is dominated by machine-made cigars that measure their sales in the billions of units.

“We’re the little guys,” said Patel. “We spent $4 million already on litigation. We’re fighting our butts off.” He also emphasized that the FDA didn’t understand the cigar business. “It’s like taking a plumber and getting him to fix the rockets on the space shuttle,” he said.

Save The Date

The next Big Smoke takes place in Hollywood, Florida, April 3-4, 2020, with Big Smoke meets WhiskyFest, an event combining the best of cigars and whisky. 

The Big Smoke Las Vegas returns to the Mirage November 20-22, 2020.

Big Smoke Evenings

2019 Big Smoke Las Vegas Evenings

Saturday Seminars

Top Three Cigars of 2018

Power Tobacco

Investing in Cuban Cigars

Women in Cigars

Fighting the FDA

Lunch with Plasencia Cigars

Sunday Seminars

Cigar Lovers' Breakfast

Roll Your Own Cigar with Ventura Cigars

Tasting Away in Tequilaville

Big Smoke 2019 J.C. Newman Cigar Co. Rocky Patel Premium Cigars

More in Cigar Industry

See all
2019 Big Smoke Las Vegas Weekend: Photo Gallery

2019 Big Smoke Las Vegas Weekend: Photo Gallery

A look back at some of the best moments from the 2019 Big Smoke Las Vegas evening parties and daytime …

Nov 22, 2019
2019 Big Smoke Sunday Seminars: Tasting Away in Tequilaville

2019 Big Smoke Sunday Seminars: Tasting Away in Tequilaville

Tequila and mezcal were the topics of the Tasting Away in Tequilaville seminar on Sunday at the 2019 …

Nov 21, 2019
2019 Big Smoke Sunday Seminars: Cigar Lovers’ Breakfast

2019 Big Smoke Sunday Seminars: Cigar Lovers’ Breakfast

The Big Smoke Sunday Seminar crowd refueled with some hearty food, strong coffee and a hair of the …

Nov 21, 2019
2019 Big Smoke Sunday Seminars: Roll Your Own Cigar

2019 Big Smoke Sunday Seminars: Roll Your Own Cigar

You will probably gain a new appreciation for cigars if you go to a factory and see how they’re made. …

Nov 21, 2019
STG Names New President of North American Online and Retail Division

STG Names New President of North American Online and Retail Division

Scandinavian Tobacco Group has announced Sarah Santos will soon take over for Craig Reynolds, the …

Nov 21, 2019
2019 Big Smoke Saturday Seminars: Lunch with Plasencia Cigars

2019 Big Smoke Saturday Seminars: Lunch with Plasencia Cigars

After a morning filled with educational seminars and no shortage of fine cigars, it was only fitting …

Nov 20, 2019