Battle at the Bar

(continued from page 2)
THE FAMOUS GROUSE GOLD RESERVE This 12-year-old Grouse has additional complexity and a stronger role for malts. Tastes of honey, rum, burnt nuts and French bread. Smoke medium to full body.
JOHNNIE WALKER Lack of an age statement belies the maturity of the Blue Label. Fruit and honey harmonize with wood, salt and peat. Pair full-bodied. The 18-year-old Gold Label isn't as complex or peaty, but makes up for it with a chewy, toasty, nutty character. Pair medium to full. Twelve-year-old Black Label pairs mild to medium.
CUTTY SARK A bright whisky, created for light tastes. Floral nose with a hint of sour wine. Peaty on the palate with chewy bread dough and almost no sweetness. Pair mild to medium.
Bourbon lacks a convenient niche by which to claim a strong cigar affinity. It's not made side by side with fine cigars like rum. (Bourbon's birthplace, Kentucky, is famous for cigarettes). It doesn't have Cognac's tradition of being sipped at elegant affairs. (Bourbon is associated with card games and horse races.) It doesn't get peat-smoked, aged for 25 years and feted in the parlors of London like Scotch. (Bourbon gets no smoke; 10 years is pretty old by its standards; until recently, a call for Bourbon in an English bar would get a glassy stare.)
No, nothing seems to argue in favor of Bourbon -- except the taste buds. The sweet, woody, creamy spirit which is Bourbon just seems to pair well with a wide range of cigars. When you scratch the surface of how the whiskey is made, this begins to makes a lot more sense.
First of all, distilling tradition is a great part of the end product. Eighteenth-century Scotch and Irish immigrants to America brought their stills and know-how with them. Eventually many headed west to Kentucky. When they arrived, they added a key component to any successful cigar/spirit interaction: sweetness. Without abundant barley and rye, they made whiskey with the local grain, corn, a far sweeter ingredient. The water was naturally filtered by a great limestone shelf.
Second, folklore tells us that serendipity added the next integral part of the formula. A Baptist minister who dabbled in distilling was cleaning a barrel with kerosene, the story goes, when it caught on fire. He doused the fire and used the cask anyway. He discovered that the charring of the inside brought out the charms of the wood much faster than normal aging. A tradition was born. Significantly, the aging was being done in Kentucky, where sweltering summers expand the whiskey into the layer of wood char, and chilly winters draw it together with the attendant flavors, back into the barrel. That explains the dearth of superannuated Bourbons.
If I were posed the same conundrum as mentioned in the section under rum -- blindfolded at a bar with a cigar and asked to make a house call based on type of spirit -- I'd make mine Bourbon.Why? Because it is the most consistent of brown goods. First, it is made in a small area of Kentucky that offers much the same climatic conditions throughout. Second, strict legal boundaries define how straight Bourbon whiskey may be made: the grain formula, or mash bill, must be corn rich (more than 50 percent, barley and rye or wheat make up the rest); distillation can be no greater than 160 proof (usually it's much lower), which insures retention of flavor from the grains, and the product must be aged a minimum of two years. (If it isn't at least four years old the label must say so, but practically none do.) Furthermore, aging must be done in new charred, white oak barrels. (The stipulation that they must be new explains why so many used barrels make their way into other uses.) And nothing but water can be added to the final product when it goes into the bottle. Both Cognac and Scotch makers can color their spirit, and rum can be flavored. Bourbon is pretty much what-you-see-is-what-you-get.
Despite the bad reputation Bourbon suffered after Prohibition (it took years to get quality products back on the shelf), Bourbon makers in the last two decades have taken a page from the Scotch makers. They have worked hard to create products that show their artistry at its utmost and most interesting levels. Small-batch and single-barrel Bourbons are part of this revolution. Most are very good with a cigar.
We would be remiss in not mentioning Bourbon's two American cousins, rye and Tennessee sour mash whiskey. The former has a longer tradition in this country than Bourbon. Settlers in Maryland and Pennsylvania found it easy to grow rye and made whiskey rich in that grain before they ever thought of corn liquor. With rye composing more than half its mash bill, it has a spicier, grainier complexion with subtleties that often enhance the enjoyment of a milder cigar. Tennessee sour mash whiskey is the category into which Jack Daniel's falls. Even though it shares most of the characteristics of a Bourbon and is often mistaken for one, Jack Daniel's (along with its lesser known neighbor George Dickel) is differentiated by its mellowing charcoal filtering. All of the above share the legal stipulations of straight whiskey, making them consistently great cigar accompaniments. Enjoy the whiskey patriotism.
WOODFORD RESERVE Made from the "honey barrels" of Brown-Forman's Old Forester, this whiskey is a confection of maple sugar, cherry, vanilla and caramel, tempered with meat and smoke. Smoke full bodied.
BOOKER'S TRUE BARREL Unfiltered and uncut, it's about 125 proof, and loaded with orange, leather, vanilla, nuts and honey. Sublime with a big cigar, death to the mild.
KNOB CREEK The anchor of Jim Beam's Small Batch collection, Knob is creamy and informed by vanilla, maple and caramel with a hint of orange. Invites a wider range of cigars than big brother Booker.
WILD TURKEY Hard to choose between WT's excellent superpremium range-Rare Breed (floral with caramel, orange, licorice and maple), Kentucky Spirit (as candied, but meater) and Russell's Reserve (the spicier offering) -- so we won't. Smoke medium to full.
BLANTON'S SINGLE BARREL The original single-barrel Bourbon, Blanton's paints a wide swath between fruity pear flavor to strong woods and a touch of grittiness. Finds a range of good cigar matches.
MAKER'S MARK Maple sweet, orange and vanilla flavored and solidly medium bodied. Pairs well with a wide range of cigars.
EVAN WILLIAMS SINGLE BARREL VINTAGE 1992 Vintage concept brings yearly variations within a medium-bodied profile. This last bottling is stronger in spice, but still sweet with orange and maple.
JACK DANIEL'S SINGLE BARREL A Tennessee sour mash whiskey, Jack Daniel's is filtered through charcoal, leaving it with orange and caramel notes and no rough edges. Exceptional with milder cigars.
OLD OVERHOLT RYE Inexpensive straightforward rye with nutmeg/
vanilla sweetness and a toasty balance. Good all-around cigar partner.
OLD RIP VAN WINKLE OLD TIME RYE A 12-year-old with oaken, yeasty flavor, as well as butter and olive oil. Pair medium to full.
SAZERAC KENTUCKY STRAIGHT RYE WHISKEY At 18 years, smooth and honeyed, with Cognac character and minty, eucalyptus spice. Full-bodied leathery cigars pair best.
Log in if you're already registered.

Or register for Cigar Aficionado today—it's free.

Registration allows you to:
  • Keep track of your favorite cigars in your personal humidor.
  • Comment on all our stories.

Forgot your password?

Ratings & Reviews

Search our database of more than 17,000 cigar tasting notes by score, brand, country, size, price range, year, wrapper and more, plus add your favorites to your Personal Humidor.