Best Bargain Cigars of 2009

Americans are natural bargain hunters. It's a national instinct that has developed over decades of comparison shopping, chasing down sales and other adapted behavior to best survive in the free market. The cigar smoker wants as much value for his dollar as anyone else, but is also cognizant of quality, perhaps more so than the average consumer, so we have amassed our annual list of high-quality, bargain cigars. This year, a bargain is defined as any cigar that costs no more than $6 and scored no less than 88 points in our ratings. The previous "bargain" cap was $5, but given inflation, rising taxes and the general increased costs of operation, we decided to raise the margin by a dollar. As a result, the list grew exponentially. These entries were taken from both Cigar Aficionado and the Cigar Insider.

Worthy of considerable attention are the Oliva Serie V Especial Belicoso, Ambos Mundos No. 2 Robusto and the Nestor Miranda Special Selection Coffee Break. Each is a bargain smoke that also appears on the Top 25. (Note that in this bargain list they appear with their original Cigar Aficionado or Cigar Insider score, which may differ from the Top 25 rating.) Not good enough? How about a Padrón robusto for $4 or a handmade Cuban Hoyo de Monterrey for even less?

If after reading this long list of inexpensive premium cigars you still cannot find anything to suit your budget, then perhaps you have taken up the wrong hobby.

91 points

Brick House Churchill, Nicaragua
7 1/4" by 50, $5.75

Hoyo de Tradición Corona, Honduras
5 3/4" by 45, $5.49

Oliva Serie O Torpedo, Nicaragua 6" by 52, .60

Oliva Serie O Torpedo, Nicaragua
6" by 52, $5.60

90 points

Ambos Mundos No. 1 Toro, Nicaragua
6" by 50, $5.25

Arturo Fuente Hemingway Short Story, Dom. Rep.
4" by 49, $5.45

Casa Magna Colorado Corona, Nicaragua
6" by 46, $4.75

Château Real Maduro Noble Habana, Nicaragua
5 1/4" by 54, $6.00

El Baton Double Robusto, Nicaragua
5" by 54, $5.75

Hoyo de Monterrey Palmas Extra, Cuba
5 1/2" by 40, 4 sw. fr.

H. Upmann Reserve Maduro Robusto, Honduras
5" by 54, $5.50

H. Upmann Reserve Maduro Churchill, Honduras
7" by 50, $6.00

La Escepción Excepcionales, Honduras
5 1/2" by 50, $5.99

La Flor Dominicana Double Ligero DL-452, Dom. Rep.
3 7/8" by 52, $4.90

Nestor Miranda Collection Special Selection Coffee Break, Nicaragua
4 1/2" by 50, $6.00

Te-Amo World Selection Series Cuba Blend Gran Corto, Mexico 4" by 62, .75

Te-Amo World Selection Series Cuba Blend Gran Corto, Mexico
4" by 62, $4.75

89 points

777 Corojo Robusto, Nicaragua
5" by 50, $5.45

777 Corojo Toro, Nicaragua
6" by 52, $5.70

Canimao Churchill, U.S.A.
7" by 48, $6.00

Cusano LXI Habano Sun Grown Perferido, Dom. Rep.
5 3/4" by 58, $5.83

Don Pepin Garcia Invictos, U.S.A.
5" by 50, $6.00

Nub Habano 460, Nicaragua
4" by 60, $5.00

Padrón 2000, Nicaragua
5" by 50, $4.00

Perdomo2 Limited Edition Maduro Epicure, Nicaragua 5 1/2" by 54, .50

Perdomo2 Limited Edition Maduro Epicure, Nicaragua
5 1/2" by 54, $5.50

Perdomo2 Limited Edition Torpedo, Nicaragua
5 1/4" by 54, $6.00

Por Larrañaga Petit Cetros en Cedro, Dom. Rep.
5 1/16" by 38, $5.20

Rocky Patel Winter Collection Corona, Nicaragua
5 1/2" by 44, $5.75

Log in if you're already registered.

Or register for Cigar Aficionado today—it's free.

Registration allows you to:
  • Keep track of your favorite cigars in your personal humidor.
  • Comment on all our stories.

Forgot your password?

Ratings & Reviews

Search our database of more than 17,000 cigar tasting notes by score, brand, country, size, price range, year, wrapper and more, plus add your favorites to your Personal Humidor.