Preview the NEW
Puffing in the 2011 Playoffs—Where to Smoke A Cigar in Baseball’s Postseason

Cigar Aficionado's guide to where you can smoke in MLB’s playoff cities.

(continued from page 2)
The Braves were ahead of the St. Louis Cardinals in the NL Wild Card race by eight-and-a-half games at the beginning of September. On the last day of the regular season, the Braves lose a heartbreaker to baseball’s best Philadelphia Phillies. St. Louis thumps the league’s worst team, the Houston Astros, and are in the playoffs. The Red Sox were up nine over the Rays for the AL Wild Card spot.
On the last night of the regular season, the tables finished turning. Call them collapses if you like. Everything changed.
The very bad Baltimore Orioles beat the Sox, scoring two in the bottom of the ninth with two out. Tampa Bay went down 7-0 to the Yankees and then scored six in the eighth and pinch-hitter Dan Johnson hit the tying homer in the ninth with two outs and two strikes. Evan Longoria of the Rays then hit a walk-off homer in the 12th. The day before, Tampa had turned a triple play to stay in the game and eventually win.
That’s baseball. Ya gotta play ‘em all.
My cousin asked me the other day, before the last day of the season, “What could be done to make baseball games more exciting?” I told him that I don’t think the game needs to go extreme. I do think that, in addition to the Baltimore Orioles returning permanently to the “Happy Bird” logo, a few adjustments are needed. Use the 40-man roster, but make only 25 players eligible at any given game. Too many pitching changes slow things down tremendously.
Just to pick up where I left you at the end of last season, baseball still needs instant replay in a big way. I still believe that would not only improve the accuracy of the calls, but ultimately speed up the game.  Will that make baseball more exciting to the casual fan? Maybe not. I don’t really care. I think baseball appeals to more types of people than does, say, football. I love—love!—baseball. I would happily watch every game of the year in the MLB Fan Cave. My favorite sport to watch, however, is hockey.  
That’s another one that seems a little too complex or inaccessible for many, even though it’s about as fast a sport as you’ll find. Having played both—and basically sucked at both—gives me insights to how difficult playing these sports really can be. And I know that in baseball, there’s always something happening every pitch even if the casual fan can’t see it.
This year, what seemed to be happening on every baseball sports show was a discussion of how to measure player performance. The latest, greatest statistic that baseball’s world of metrics has popularized is “WAR.” The acronym stands for “wins above replacement.”
Simply, WAR seeks to measure the value of a starting player against the likely less-expensive replacement that could be found. So, for example, Matt Kemp, the LA Dodgers center fielder, is having a career year and with five games left had a WAR ranking of about 9.6, the highest in baseball this year. By comparison, Ryan Braun, the Milwaukee Brewers left fielder and Kemp’s main rival for the NL MVP this year, has a WAR ranking of 7.2, even though Braun’s team has clinched its division’s crown, something that the Brewers probably wouldn’t have done without Braun’s performance. For reference, in 2004, Barry Bonds had a WAR of 12.4.
In the AL, even though Curtis Granderson of the Yankees is my narrow winner for MVP, his WAR is about 7. Jose “Joey Bats” Bautista, Toronto’s slugger, is at 8.2, and Boston’s Jacoby Ellsbury, also an MVP favorite, ranks 8.5, with his teammate Dustin Pedroia at 7.3.
WAR is designed to be able to have one statistic, admittedly comprised of numerous other statistics, define the value of a player. (If you want to know how WAR is calculated, Google “MLB WAR.”) The focus on WAR during all the baseball talk shows is appropriate if you want to get down to one number. It’s one of those tools that tells you little about a team game, unless maybe you’ve got the top 10 players by WAR ranking on one team, including four pitchers. Don’t even get me started on WHIP.
The 2011 season started with a San Francisco Giants fan on opening day in Los Angeles getting beaten into a coma by two erstwhile Dodgers “fans” who reportedly have stronger ties to some local gang. The Dodgers’ season was ending with a surprisingly strong finish on the field and a thoroughly embarrassing procession in bankruptcy court where MLB has asked a judge to force parking-lot magnate Frank McCourt to sell the team. The best single stat to measure McCourt’s impact on the Dodgers is “PAOFITS,” or “paid-attendance-over-fans-in-the-stands.”
View from Camacho Cigar Bar inside the Detroit Tiger's Comerica Park.
View from Camacho Cigar Bar inside the Detroit Tiger's Comerica Park.
Basically, by the end of the season, about half the fans who had paid for tickets were going to the stadium to see Kemp try to become the first Triple Crown winner since 1967. His teammate, Clayton Kershaw, looks likely to win the Cy Young this year, with his own pitching triple crown. Kershaw is tied for most wins (21), lowest ERA (2.28) and most strikeouts (248).
The 2011 season was also about injuries, perhaps the most prominent of which was Buster Posey’s torn ligaments and broken left ankle. Posey, the catcher and key to the San Francisco Giants’ World Series win last year, was playing against the Florida Marlins when Scott Cousins, attempting to score on a sacrifice fly, collided with Posey, who was trying to block the plate. Posey fell back awkwardly and Cousins scored. Posey was out for the season. The Giants also suffered from injuries to their closer Brian Wilson.
Other prominent injuries included Alex Rodriguez, who will not hit 30 home runs for the first time since 1997, his third year in the league. More recently, most of the starting rotation for the Boston Red Sox was beaten up, leaving the team to rely on the Baltimore Orioles to beat up on the Tampa Bay Rays, the team that challenged the BoSox for the Wild Card.
The Atlanta Braves, impressive all year, also started to fold towards the end as the St. Louis Cardinals pressed for the Wild Card spot. Do we even need to talk about the “first to worst” Minnesota Twins? We should talk about the “worst to first” Arizona Diamondbacks.
As always, there were some amazing plays made by players you’d never heard of (Ben Revere, Roger Bernadina, Adam Jones, Sam Fuld) and a lot of unbelievable ones made by Cleveland Indians shortstop Asdrubal Cabrera, who also set a team record this year for homers by a Tribe shortstop. Cabrera made the behind-the-back flip to second his own, while just about everybody, most notably Cincinnati’s “Mr. Personality,” second baseman Brandon Phillips, made a glove flip to first between the legs.
A notable accomplishment was Mariano Rivera breaking Trevor Hoffman’s save record. And congratulations to Derek Jeter for becoming the first Yankees player to get 3,000 hits, and to Jim Thome for passing the 600 home run mark.
And finally, can we say goodbye forever to Manny Ramirez? And maybe Carlos Zambrano? A question all to itself: What is up with Nyjer Morgan?
The year ends with big question marks about two certified superstars and where they will end up next season. Albert Pujols, who, despite injuries early in the year, still hit .300 with 37 dingers, was in the last year of his contract with the St. Louis Cardinals. Prince Fielder, the Brewers first baseman, is a little younger and has a slightly lower average than Pujols, and has already said this is likely his last year in Milwaukee. The interesting stat to look for in both cases is the dollars each will get as a free agent.
For me, 2011 was a season mostly focused on baseball’s sometimes amusing ownership issues. Of course, the stadium closest to me is in Chavez Ravine. In addition to the Dodgers, the Mets are in the most dire financial straits. There are too many teams and not enough major-league talent. That, I think, was made clearest in Houston as Drayton McLane tries to sell the Astros to controversial businessman Jim Crane for $680 million, the second-highest price for a major league team. Whether MLB will approve the sale remains a question. The biggest concern, reportedly that $300 million of the deal would be debt-financed, is that Crane would become another Frank McCourt. Anyone got Mark Cuban’s phone number?
The last week of the regular season might indeed prove more exciting than any playoffs. The wild finishes in the Wild Card races make the match-ups in the postseason a lot more interesting than they appeared to be a month earlier.
Here’s who’s going to play who in the first round of the playoffs and who’s going to win each round. A lot of my picks are based largely on how teams are playing now, not their head-to-head records.
Oy. The Yankees. Again? The Bombers, with the league’s best record, will play the Detroit Tigers, a team that hits the ball well and pitches better. This one begins in the Bronx and I figure about three rain delays in the series. That benefits the Yankees because they could then pitch C.C. Sabathia and Iván Nova in all four games needed to win.
The Tigers boast Justin Verlander, a lock on this year’s Cy Young in the AL and late-season acquisition Doug Fister, an impressive number two starter. The Tigers also have baseball’s best closer, Jose Valverde, who notched 49 saves without blowing one this year. I pick the Tigers in five.
The Texas Rangers begin at home against the charging Rays. Tampa probably has the best starting pitching of the four teams in the AL playoffs, but the arms are a little worn. Texas just crushes the ball against anyone. The Rangers want to get back to the World Series and avenge last year’s defeat to the Giants. I see the Rangers moving on, deflating the Rays in four. After that, I have the Rangers moving on to the championship.
The Phillies. That’s about all you need to say. Unless you also want to say the Brewers. Philadelphia has all that pitching and all that hitting and played like the “cheese” they put on cheese steaks down the stretch. You know? Like crap. The hitting that did not show up against the Giants last year was again not showing up in the last 10 games of the year. The Phils starters are pretty much healthy and they’ve added right fielder Hunter Pence, who has apparently brought some fire to the team.  
Philadelphia will play the surprising wild-Cardinals. Philly will throw Roy Halladay, Cliff Lee, Cole Hamels and, maybe, Roy Oswalt at the redbirds. Phenom Vance Worley goes to the bullpen as the long-reliever. Then there’s still Joe Blanton and closer Ryan Madson. They’ll be facing Pujols, Lance Berkman and Matt Holliday, always fearsome bats, with the addition of Rafael Furcal at short and leadoff adding a dimension the Cards had missed most of the year. Still, the Fightins move on.
The only official Cigar Aficionado lounge in the world, inside New York's Cigar Inn.
The only official Cigar Aficionado lounge in the world, inside New York's Cigar Inn.
The Arizona Diamondbacks, who won the relatively weak west in Kirk Gibson’s rookie year as manager, get the misfortune of facing the Milwaukee Brewers. Arizona also saw the emergence of Justin Upton as a star and benefitted from a solid enough year from centerfielder Chris Young. Aaron Hill was a late season acquisition from Toronto and is helping fill holes in the lineup. Ian Kennedy, a former Yankees pitcher, won 21 games as a starter.
Milwaukee has surprisingly good pitching this year, with Yovani Gallardo, Zack Greinke, Shaun Marcum and Randy Wolf. Milwaukee has John Axford closing games, being set up by Frankie “K-Rod” Rodriguez, who seems to find ways to say or do the wrong thing at the worst time every year.  Milwaukee, whose hitting has been inconsistent beyond Braun and Fielder most of the year, will score enough against a Snakes pitching staff with a combined 3.78 ERA. That’s not much worse than Milwaukee’s at 3.64, but it’s enough of a difference.
David Savona September 29, 2011 4:53pm ET
I like your story, but not your picks. Yanks in five.
Arthur Pappas MA, September 29, 2011 5:03pm ET
May I also make a shamless plug for Cigar Masters in Worcester MA as a great place to watch a game (even though the Red Sox broke our hearts)?
Chris Homan Coldwater, OH, USA, September 30, 2011 7:49am ET
I'll be watching playoff baseball from the comfort of my own home, with good cigars and scotch on hand, being that my team didn't make it. I really don't care who wins, as long as it's not the Yankees. The only team in professional sports that I loathe more is the Green Bay Packers.
David Savona September 30, 2011 9:43am ET
Funny Arthur, all my friends who are Red Sox fans have shown zero interest in watching the playoffs this year. And Chris, why all the Yankee hatred?
Alex Benes Newbury Park, CA, USA, September 30, 2011 2:21pm ET
Watching from home is the best, really. I turn my screen towards the porch and look through the glass door. I light a big cigar and pour a huge glass of rum and sit back. It's always good weather here!
Chris Homan Coldwater, OH, USA, September 30, 2011 5:58pm ET

I've just never liked the Yankees, and them winninng everything under the sun, going out an dspending money on big-name guys, and having the sports media ramming them down my throat every day gets really old. I know there's a lot of history there, and i can appreciate that, but I just can't stand the Yankees.
David Wisniewski Pennsauken, NJ, USA, October 1, 2011 8:19pm ET
Total agreement with your view on the Yankees, but I want to see them represent the AL, so, the Phils can put those cry babys and their bandwagon fans in their place, once and for all.
Chris Homan Coldwater, OH, USA, October 7, 2011 9:10am ET
Ding dong, the Yanks are GONE!!!! :)

Sorry, couldn't resist.

Log in if you're already registered.

Or register for Cigar Aficionado today—it's free.

Registration allows you to:
  • Keep track of your favorite cigars in your personal humidor.
  • Comment on all our stories.

Forgot your password?

Ratings & Reviews

Search our database of more than 17,000 cigar tasting notes by score, brand, country, size, price range, year, wrapper and more, plus add your favorites to your Personal Humidor.