Smoking Scene



I went to Club Macanudo last night with some friends. I was hardly ready for another cigar; we’d spent the afternoon working through the final selection for the next Top Cigar of the Year. A bit smoked out, and tired, I walked up Madison Avenue, past stores still lit up but empty of shoppers, and that was a nerve-wracking reminder of all the financial news that had been flashing across my computer screen all day—and Thursday was a good, albeit pretty tumultuous, day on Wall Street.

So when I walked through the door of Club Macanudo, and was hit by the sweet aroma of good cigars, I was little surprised at my reaction; a deep breath and a sigh of relief and a glow of pleasure. I felt like I was walking into a living room filled with friends.

My friend was already at the bar with a glass of wine, and a cigar given to him by the man who was the main reason we were all gathering, Arek Aboulian of Raffi’s cigar shop in Geneva, Switzerland. Arek had joined James Suckling at the Las Vegas Big Smoke for a panel on the state of the Cuban cigar industry, and was passing through New York on his way home to meet with some folks who frequent his store in Switzerland.

Arek handed me a wonderful aged cigar of “unknown” origin. I ordered a glass of Montecristo Rum on the rocks. And immediately, I was transported leagues away from the cares of the day. My friend and I began talking about golf and cigars and stories about our kids; he won the kid story competition but I won’t repeat it here. We were joined by more of his friends, some of whom I also knew from Sleepy Hollow Country Club.

I had said I could only spend about an hour there, and when I finally looked down at my watch, the hour had passed, and I had to leave. Fortunately, the cigar was down to the last third, although it was still painful to leave it behind. It was also hard to leave. The camaraderie and relaxation was just what the doctor would have ordered. And, I was reminded once again about the reasons we all love to share a great cigar and a glass of our favorite adult beverage with friends.
Carl Diorio November 14, 2008 10:52am ET
Great place with great staff and customers. Had a terrific time there a few months back on a visit to NYV with my galpal. We were both tickled pink by the opportunity to sit and have a civilized meal topped off by a couple great cigars (over dessert, actually!).
Carl Diorio November 14, 2008 10:53am ET
Great place with great staff and customers. Had a terrific time there a few months back on a visit to NYC with my galpal. We were both tickled pink by the opportunity to sit and have a civilized meal topped off by a couple great cigars (over dessert, actually!).
Manny Iriarte Miami, Florida November 14, 2008 11:58am ET
Mr. Mott,I feel the same way. I haven't had the opportunity to visit Club Macanudo in NY, but we have in Miami, FL.Every time I go I enjoy the amazing relaxation with a good smoke, a drink and a friend or two.Having to get up and leave is difficult after a great moment.
Luis Falto Mayaguez, Puerto Rico November 24, 2008 11:31am ET
What you just related to us is a big part of what cigar smoking is all about. Memorable moments like that, help aliviate any worries of daily life. Thanks for sharing with us.

Log in if you're already registered.

Or register for Cigar Aficionado today—it's free.


Registration allows you to:
  • Keep track of your favorite cigars in your personal humidor.
  • Comment on all our stories.

Forgot your password?



Ratings & Reviews

Search our database of more than 17,000 cigar tasting notes by score, brand, country, size, price range, year, wrapper and more, plus add your favorites to your Personal Humidor.