Preview the NEW CigarAficionado.com
Atabey and an Argument for Good Packaging



A curious delivery came to me in the mail the other day. Cigars. Nothing strange in that respect, but when I opened it, I was struck by the packaging. To be honest, I was more than struck. I was impressed.

Now, anytime you talk about packaging in the cigar world, you often get a knee-jerk uproar of dismissive barking from the righteous and the skeptical: "I don't care about packaging, I just care about the cigar," or "You don't smoke the box, you smoke the tobacco," or "You're just paying for the packaging. It's all—" Let me stop you right there.

The thing is, you do care about packaging. Either you don't know it or you won't admit it. And there's nothing wrong with appreciating or even wanting smart design in your cigar boxes and bands. It doesn't mean that you're some rube whose fallen prey to a marketing gimmick or the victim of well-planned psychological warfare. Packaging is there to foreshadow and address the upcoming experience.

But like it or not, packaging is part of the entire experience. If you have a quality product, you want it to be confirmed by a tactile and visually appealing exterior. Good cigars deserve good, conscientious packaging. That's where it starts. And not everyone can do it effectively. Most cigarmakers know this.

Nelson Alfonso knows this. You might not know the name, but many in the industry do. He's the imagery and creative director for the Golden Age design firm. They handle most of the major branding for Habanos S.A. and Alfonso has been instrumental on the Cuban Cohiba design since 1999. While he didn't design the original logo, he has developed it over time and brought it to where it is today. And Nelson Alfonso also designed Padron's 50th Anniversary humidor.

So when I opened the curious package, the first thing I thought was "Cohiba." But not today's Cohiba. Not even the Cohiba of the last two decades. I was thinking the old Cohiba logos with the tobacco leaf and black Taino head and no trace of yellow. Remember those?

I held the new, mysterious box. The texture has a lovely matte finish and is protected by an outer shell clasped shut by a beautiful and ornate "sello de Garantita," or guarantee seal. The seal really has the look and artistry of well-minted, old-world stock certificates, not just some lame attempt at the vintage look. Once you break the seal of the outer shell, an inner box slides out nicely.

Atabey cigars and packaging.

The bottom half of the box is a pleasant shade of off-white; the top, a grid of dots. A black line divides the two and there's a tribal-looking head in the middle over a mysterious word in blocky letters: Atabey. It's a strange and simple word. Kind of like Cohiba. Same amount of syllables. Same amount of letters.

Atabey, in Cuban mythology, was a female goddess of the Taino tribe. Makes sense. If Habanos is going to claim a Taino as their own with Cohiba—and also take ownership of the Taino head priest (Bejique. Or Behike), then I guess Atabey is up for grabs.

Alfonso, however, wasn't the first person in the cigar world to think of using Atabey. It's also the name of the holding company behind the little known, Miami-made Canimao brand owned by Mel Gonzalez. No relation. But back to Alfonso.

On top of being a designer, Alfonso is a cigarmaker as well. Or, more appropriately, cigar blender. I don't think he actually rolls anything. I'm not clear on whether or not he's ever actually rolled cigars or has any formal factory training. All I know is that Atabey is his brand.

And once you slide the inner box out of the protective shell, what you get is a curious sampler of five different Atabey cigars. They are individually packaged in humidified glass tubes. The humidifying element is on the bottom, and there's even a punch cutter on top. It even comes with a little bottle of humidification fluid. Smart Nelson. Very smart.

If you've never heard of Atabey, let me acquaint you as best I can. They're made in Costa Rica. The blend is one that's pretty popular these days in premium cigars: Ecuador Havana wrapper and mostly Nicaraguan guts. And they're distributed by a company called United Cigar Group, which is owned and operated by David Garofalo. You know Dave. He also owns Two Guys Smoke shop in New Hampshire. Atabey cigars have been around for a few years, but distribution is now in United's hands.

So how's the cigar? I chose the Divinos size because it's the smallest of the five (4 1/2 inches by 50 ring), and I tend to gravitate towards smaller cigars. I was impressed by its ability to produce fairly sophisticated flavor, but at the same time stay in the mild to medium-bodied range. It had an easygoing floral quality with some very light sweet-and-salty underpinnings, kind of like a salted caramel. So many times a mild cigar ends up being a smoke that tastes like straw hay, grass and a bit of paper. Not so here.

But here's another notable fact. The Atabey Divinos retails for $19.99 each. And that's the smallest size. The largest size, Delerios (5 3/4 by 55) retails for $29.99 each. And now the question I'm often asked about any cigar that retails for more than $10: Is it worth it? That question is impossible to answer. Budgets are varied, personal and arbitrary. Value calls are even more personal and arbitrary, so I can't answer it definitively. What I can say about this cigar is that it's interesting, enjoyable and definitely worth trying. But only you can make the value call.

I wonder if Alfonso had a particular Cuban cigar in mind when he came up with Atabey. Was he chasing the Cuban ghost like so many other cigarmakers have in the passed, or did he just intuitively blend to personal taste. Maybe he created a packaging concept first, and then sought a cigar that lived up to the design. It's difficult for me to tell just by smoking and I'm not presumptuous enough to hazard a guess. Either way, the cigar lived up to its packaging. And if the packaging is the culmination of Alfonso's life in design, then it probably isn't too out of line to say that cigar blend is a sincere culmination of his life as a cigar smoker.

hans muller Geneva, Switzerland, Switzerland, Switzerland, February 8, 2015 2:41pm ET
Hallo Sir Mottola.

I am from Switzerland, and here we use to smoke mostly Cuban cigars.
A friend of us who lives in Boston, that also only smoke Cuban cigars, bring us 6 month ago a beautiful porcelain Jar with 25 Atabey of the size -Brujos- cause he wanted that we test this cigars he consider fabulous. To be honest, we did not believe him at all; despite he smokes only Cubans from more than 30 years ago.

Once we smoke them here we get very impressed about that amazing cigar. The construction, aroma, and test is "over" the perfection. We really don't know how they made them. It's like to smoke a very refined Cuban cigars from the 80`s.

We never have seen the pack of tubes on the photo of your blog. We only know them in jars.

As long as we know this cigars is only available in USA because the company who produce this cigars do not distribute them in the rest of the world. That´s is something we really don't know why.

Thanks Mr. Mottola for your detailed report that have given us more information about this brand.

Liebe grüße,

Hans Müller
Cigar Connoisseurs
Geneva

John O'Neill Brick, NJ, US, February 10, 2015 5:39am ET
I would have to agree that packaging is a major part on selling points. And this cigar has caught my eye. I just put it on my list as a must have. It looks great and I'm sure it is a amazing stick that I have to try. Not to mention they will be a great conversation piece to show off!!
John O'Neill Brick, NJ, US, February 10, 2015 5:39am ET
I would have to agree that packaging is a major part on selling points. And this cigar has caught my eye. I just put it on my list as a must have. It looks great and I'm sure it is a amazing stick that I have to try. Not to mention they will be a great conversation piece to show off!!
Alejandro Benes Newbury Park, CA, USA, February 10, 2015 5:39pm ET
Greg, I DO smoke the packaging. Sadly, quite often it tastes better than the cigars inside. All the best, Alex
Deric Metzger Oceanside, CA - California, United States, February 11, 2015 7:51am ET
Packaging is presentation. Presentation is psychodrama. Psychodrama creates what boils down to a natural performance enhancing drug cocktail of endorphins and hormones. They heighten the sensations and the overall pleasure of the experience.

If your attitude is that "all packaging gimmicks are there to hide a crap cigar" then you ARE getting the same neuro-chemical rush made to heighten your senses-as designed-but you are primarily focused on the desire to prove yourself right (what a curious and base human need). On the other hand, an actually crap cigar will still be constructed poorly, and taste awful, regardless of the packaging.

What is more important? Enjoying the experience and allowing it to overtake you in a positive way, or being "right"? Even if you're not?
Taylor Franklin June 8, 2015 9:11pm ET
These cigars are fantastic some of the best I've ever put a match to and worth the super-prermium price. Granted they're special occasion smokes at least for me, something of this calibre ought to be celebrated and shared in good company with warm conversation.

Log in if you're already registered.

Or register for Cigar Aficionado today—it's free.


Registration allows you to:
  • Keep track of your favorite cigars in your personal humidor.
  • Comment on all our stories.

Forgot your password?



Ratings & Reviews

Search our database of more than 17,000 cigar tasting notes by score, brand, country, size, price range, year, wrapper and more, plus add your favorites to your Personal Humidor.